Reddit User Sentiment Towards “Law Abiding Citizen”: Movies Like Law Abiding Citizen Reddit
Reddit discussions surrounding “Law Abiding Citizen” reveal a complex and often divided user base. While the film’s premise and execution garner significant praise for its dark themes and morally ambiguous protagonist, criticism often centers on plot contrivances and character inconsistencies. The overall sentiment is far from unanimous, with passionate arguments on both sides of the fence.
Analysis of Reddit User Reviews
The following table summarizes common sentiments expressed by Reddit users regarding different aspects of “Law Abiding Citizen.” These examples are drawn from various threads and comments across multiple subreddits, reflecting a broad range of opinions.
| Sentiment | Specific Aspect of the Film | User Quote (Paraphrased) | Reason for Sentiment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Positive | Plot Twists | “The film kept me guessing until the very end. I didn’t see the final reveal coming.” | Unexpected plot developments and a satisfyingly complex narrative are frequently cited as strengths. |
| Positive | Clyde Shelton’s Character | “Shelton is a terrifyingly compelling villain; you almost sympathize with him despite his actions.” | The morally grey nature of the protagonist and his methodical approach to revenge resonate with many viewers. |
| Negative | Plot Holes | “Some of the plot points felt convenient and unbelievable, particularly towards the climax.” | Certain plot elements are criticized for lacking realism or sufficient explanation, leading to inconsistencies. |
| Negative | Character Development | “The supporting characters felt underdeveloped and lacked depth, serving primarily to advance Shelton’s plan.” | Many users feel the supporting cast lacked sufficient background or motivations, making them less impactful. |
| Positive | Gerard Butler’s Performance | “Butler delivered a fantastic performance. He perfectly captured the chilling intelligence and simmering rage of Shelton.” | Butler’s acting is often praised for its intensity and ability to portray a complex, morally ambiguous character. |
| Neutral | Overall Film Quality | “It’s a fun, albeit flawed, thriller. Worth a watch if you enjoy revenge stories, but don’t expect perfection.” | This reflects a common sentiment where viewers acknowledge both the film’s strengths and weaknesses, resulting in a balanced opinion. |
Comparison with Similar Films
“Law Abiding Citizen” occupies a unique space within the vigilante justice subgenre, distinguishing itself through its meticulous planning and the protagonist’s chillingly methodical approach. Comparing it to other films exploring similar themes reveals both its originality and its place within a broader cinematic landscape. This comparison will focus on plot structures, character motivations, and the overall tone to highlight the nuances of “Law Abiding Citizen”‘s portrayal of revenge and justice.
“Law Abiding Citizen” shares thematic similarities with several films exploring the complexities of vigilante justice, but differs significantly in its execution and overall message. Analyzing these differences illuminates the film’s unique contribution to the genre. We will examine three prominent examples: “Death Wish,” “The Dark Knight,” and “John Wick.”
Comparison with “Death Wish”
“Death Wish,” in its various iterations, presents a more straightforward depiction of vigilante justice. Paul Kersey, the protagonist, is driven by grief and anger to become a violent force against crime after his family is brutally attacked. Unlike Clyde Shelton in “Law Abiding Citizen,” Kersey lacks the same level of meticulous planning and strategic foresight. His actions are more reactive and emotionally driven, leading to a more chaotic and less controlled descent into violence. The film’s tone is generally grittier and more straightforward, focusing on the visceral aspects of revenge rather than the intricate game of cat and mouse present in “Law Abiding Citizen.”
Comparison with “The Dark Knight”
“The Dark Knight” offers a more nuanced perspective on vigilante justice, exploring the moral ambiguities of Batman’s actions. While Batman operates within a framework of self-imposed rules, his methods are still undeniably violent and outside the law. The film presents a compelling moral dilemma, contrasting Batman’s actions with those of the Joker, a chaotic agent of anarchy. Unlike Clyde Shelton, who meticulously targets specific individuals, Batman confronts a broader criminal network. The film’s tone is darker and more complex, grappling with philosophical questions about justice, order, and chaos, which “Law Abiding Citizen” largely avoids in favor of a more focused narrative on revenge.
Comparison with “John Wick”
“John Wick” shares “Law Abiding Citizen”‘s focus on meticulous planning and execution, but with a vastly different tone and motivation. John Wick’s revenge is fueled by a personal betrayal and the loss of his car, a symbolic representation of his past life. While both protagonists demonstrate impressive skills and planning, John Wick’s actions are driven by a more visceral and personal sense of loss, lacking the intellectual and calculated approach of Clyde Shelton. The overall tone of “John Wick” is stylish and action-oriented, whereas “Law Abiding Citizen” maintains a consistently tense and suspenseful atmosphere.
Key Distinctions in the Portrayal of Revenge and Justice
The following bullet points highlight the key distinctions in how revenge and justice are portrayed in each film:
- “Law Abiding Citizen”: Revenge is meticulously planned and executed as a calculated act of retribution against a flawed system. Justice is viewed as unattainable through conventional means, necessitating vigilante action.
- “Death Wish”: Revenge is impulsive and emotionally driven, resulting in a chaotic and often self-destructive cycle of violence. Justice is sought through raw power and personal retribution, ignoring the legal system.
- “The Dark Knight”: The film explores the moral ambiguity of vigilante justice, presenting a complex debate about the effectiveness and ethical implications of extrajudicial actions. Justice is a blurry concept, constantly challenged by the actions of both Batman and the Joker.
- “John Wick”: Revenge is a highly stylized and efficient operation, fueled by personal loss. Justice is largely absent, replaced by a brutal and effective self-administered form of retribution within a specific, self-contained world.
Analysis of the Film’s Moral Ambiguity
“Law Abiding Citizen” presents a deeply unsettling moral dilemma, forcing viewers to confront the complexities of justice and revenge. The film deliberately avoids easy answers, leaving the audience to grapple with the justifications and consequences of Clyde Shelton’s actions. While he acts as a vigilante, his motivations stem from a profound sense of injustice, highlighting the flaws within the legal system itself. This ambiguity makes the film far more thought-provoking than a simple action thriller.
The moral complexities arise from the stark contrast between Shelton’s methods and his ultimate goal: justice. He operates outside the law, employing brutal and often illegal tactics to punish those responsible for the murder of his family. However, his actions are a direct response to a system that failed him, a system that allowed the guilty to walk free. This creates a compelling argument for his actions, even if those actions are reprehensible.
Arguments for Clyde Shelton’s Actions
Shelton’s actions, while extreme, can be viewed as a desperate attempt to achieve justice denied by a corrupt and inefficient legal system. The failure of the justice system to properly prosecute the perpetrators of the crime against his family is the central catalyst for his actions. His actions highlight the frustration and sense of powerlessness felt by victims when the official channels fail to deliver justice. One could argue that his actions are a form of self-help, a necessary response to a broken system that leaves victims with no other recourse. This is a powerful argument, even if one does not condone his methods.
Arguments Against Clyde Shelton’s Actions, Movies like law abiding citizen reddit
Conversely, Shelton’s methods are undeniably violent and unlawful. He operates outside the bounds of the law, violating the rights of others and undermining the very system he claims to be correcting. His actions, however justified in his own mind, lead to further suffering and create a dangerous precedent. The film also shows that his pursuit of justice, though seemingly effective in the short term, ultimately leads to a cycle of violence with devastating consequences for innocent bystanders. The film implies that even if the legal system is flawed, vigilantism is not the solution and can cause further damage.
Hypothetical Alternative Outcome
Imagine a scenario where the legal system actually functioned effectively. If the initial trial had resulted in a just verdict, with the perpetrators receiving appropriate punishment, Shelton would not have been driven to such extremes. This hypothetical outcome could involve a highly competent prosecutor, thorough investigation, and a jury that carefully considered all evidence. Such a scenario, though fictional within the context of the film, underscores the crucial role of a functioning legal system in preventing vigilantism and maintaining social order. This alternative demonstrates that the root of Shelton’s actions lies not in a desire for violence itself, but in a complete lack of faith in the legal process, a faith that could have been restored had the system worked as intended.
Impact and Legacy of “Law Abiding Citizen”
“Law Abiding Citizen,” despite its controversial themes and graphic violence, has left a lasting mark on popular culture and the thriller genre. Its exploration of vigilante justice, the flaws within the legal system, and the moral ambiguity of its protagonist Clyde Shelton resonated with audiences and continues to spark debate, securing its place in cinematic history. The film’s influence extends beyond its immediate box office success, impacting how subsequent films approach similar narratives.
The film’s impact is evident in its stylistic influence on subsequent thrillers. The meticulously planned and executed acts of revenge, the cat-and-mouse game between Clyde and the system, and the morally gray area occupied by the protagonist have become recurring elements in films exploring similar themes. The film’s use of suspense, punctuated by moments of intense violence, has also become a template for other thrillers aiming for a similar visceral impact.
Influence on Subsequent Films and Television
“Law Abiding Citizen” has demonstrably influenced the portrayal of vigilante justice in subsequent films and television shows. Many films and series have explored similar themes of flawed justice systems and individuals taking the law into their own hands, often mirroring the calculated and methodical approach showcased by Clyde Shelton. For instance, the Netflix series “Ozark” features characters who engage in morally questionable acts to protect their families, echoing the desperate measures taken by Shelton to achieve his goals. Similarly, the intricate plotting and the protagonist’s intellectual superiority over the authorities, a key element of “Law Abiding Citizen,” can be seen reflected in various crime thrillers that followed, including certain aspects of the character development in the “John Wick” franchise. The meticulous planning and execution of revenge seen in “Law Abiding Citizen” finds echoes in numerous subsequent films focusing on vigilante justice, demonstrating the film’s lasting influence on the genre’s narrative conventions.
Enduring Appeal Despite Controversial Content
The enduring appeal of “Law Abiding Citizen” lies in its unflinching portrayal of a deeply flawed system and the compelling, albeit morally reprehensible, character of Clyde Shelton. Audiences are drawn to the film’s exploration of complex themes, including the frustration with ineffective legal processes and the seductive allure of revenge. The film doesn’t shy away from showing the brutality of Shelton’s actions, yet it also presents a compelling argument for his motivations, creating a morally ambiguous character that continues to fascinate viewers. This ambiguity, coupled with the film’s suspenseful plot and well-crafted characters, ensures its continued relevance and discussion among film enthusiasts. The film’s willingness to tackle controversial subjects and challenge conventional morality provides a significant part of its enduring appeal. It prompts viewers to question the justice system and consider the potential consequences of unchecked power, regardless of whether that power is wielded by the state or by an individual.
Visual and Audio Elements of the Film
“Law Abiding Citizen” masterfully utilizes its visual and audio elements to create a gripping and unsettling atmosphere, enhancing the narrative’s themes of revenge, justice, and moral ambiguity. The film’s stylistic choices are integral to its impact, going beyond mere surface-level aesthetics to actively shape the viewer’s emotional response. The cinematography, sound design, and their interplay are carefully crafted to build suspense, amplify tension, and underscore the psychological torment of its characters.
The film’s cinematography employs a distinct visual style that mirrors the protagonist Clyde Shelton’s descent into darkness. Dark, shadowy compositions frequently dominate, emphasizing the clandestine nature of his actions and the moral gray areas he inhabits. The use of low-key lighting creates a sense of unease and mystery, reflecting the unpredictable nature of Shelton’s plans. Conversely, scenes within the brightly lit courtroom contrast sharply, highlighting the inherent hypocrisy and flaws within the legal system that Shelton seeks to expose. This juxtaposition of light and shadow underscores the film’s central conflict – the clash between seemingly ordered justice and the chaotic reality of revenge.
Cinematography and Mood Enhancement
The film’s use of long takes and deliberate camera movements contributes significantly to the building tension. Slow, deliberate pans across meticulously staged scenes allow the audience to absorb the details, fostering a sense of anticipation and dread. For instance, the extended shots during Clyde’s meticulous planning sequences build suspense, letting the viewer participate in the unfolding of his complex strategy. The camera often lingers on Clyde’s face, capturing his controlled rage and chilling determination, further enhancing the sense of impending doom. In contrast, quicker cuts are employed during moments of heightened action or violence, creating a jarring effect that amplifies the visceral impact of these events.
Sound Design and Suspense
The sound design in “Law Abiding Citizen” is equally crucial in establishing a suspenseful atmosphere. The film uses a combination of diegetic and non-diegetic sound to heighten tension and create a sense of unease. Diegetic sounds, such as the creaking of doors, the ticking of clocks, and the muffled sounds of struggle, create a palpable sense of realism and immediacy. These sounds, often subtly placed in the mix, serve as constant reminders of the lurking threat and the precariousness of the situation. Non-diegetic sounds, such as unsettling musical cues and ominous ambient soundscapes, amplify the film’s overall mood, creating a sense of foreboding and psychological pressure.
Key Scene Analysis: The First Murder
A particularly effective example of the interplay between visual and audio elements is the scene depicting the first murder Clyde orchestrates. Visually, the scene is staged in a dimly lit, claustrophobic environment, emphasizing the vulnerability of the victim. The camera focuses on small details – a glint of metal, a subtle shift in the victim’s expression – heightening the sense of impending doom. Simultaneously, the sound design intensifies the suspense. A low, throbbing bassline underscores the scene’s tension, while subtle, almost imperceptible creaks and groans build anticipation. The sudden, sharp sounds of violence are then juxtaposed with the chilling silence that follows, leaving the viewer with a profound sense of unease and moral ambiguity. This careful combination of visual and auditory elements creates a powerful and disturbing emotional impact, leaving the audience unsettled and questioning the nature of justice itself.
Essential Questionnaire
Movies like law abiding citizen reddit – What are some common criticisms of “Law Abiding Citizen” found on Reddit?
Common criticisms include the film’s glorification of violence, its unrealistic portrayal of the legal system, and the potentially problematic depiction of the protagonist’s actions.
Are there any similar movies that offer a more nuanced perspective on vigilante justice?
Yes, films like “The Dark Knight” and “John Wick” explore vigilante justice but often present more complex moral dilemmas and explore the consequences of such actions in greater depth.
How does the film’s soundtrack contribute to its overall impact?
The film’s score utilizes a blend of intense orchestral pieces and unsettling electronic soundscapes to heighten the suspense and reflect the emotional turmoil of the characters.
What makes “Law Abiding Citizen” endure despite its controversial themes?
Its compelling narrative, strong performances, and exploration of complex moral dilemmas continue to engage viewers, sparking debate and ensuring its continued relevance.